|
The course of markets is never smooth. After
the blows of 2008, we entered 2009 with
trepidation. Markets held, fell, rallied and
are in a current state of nervous equilibrium.
It seems as if we have held on by the skin of
our teeth. So what sense do we make of this,
and what now?
In the first few months of the year,
government took center stage. Wall Street,
accustomed to ignoring the beltway, took in
every word and misstatement by a young
government finding its feet in the debris of
the outgoing administration. New initiatives
poured forth: stress tests for financial
institutions, a Term Asset- Backed Securities
Loan Facility (TALF) to induce investors to
buy consumer loans, a Private Public
Partnership (PPP) to purchase the infamous
toxic assets, an extension of the TARP, a
Treasury buy-back program, a GM revival plan,
talks of currency depreciation and a change in
FASB accounting rules. The markets digested
the news as best they could but took comfort
in fundamentals. And this is where the picture
encourages us.
Economy: the news has been
grim. Housing starts, industrial production
and capacity utilization have all recorded
lower levels of activity. What makes this
recession different is a) it is global, b) it
is balance sheet-driven and c) it started in
the financial industry. The global nature of
the recession means that one country cannot
pull out the others. What we need, and G20
consensus gives us some comfort, is
coordinated policy to not make things worse.
This seems easy, but governments are always
one populist step away from protectionism,
tariffs and currency manipulation. So far so
good. Nor can consumers anywhere come to the
rescue. They are too indebted, and with home
values falling, it is illogical to expect a
snap-back. Western financial institutions,
mostly in the U.S., have unrealized losses of
another $1 trillion, on top of the $1.5
trillion already acknowledged. This means that
loan volume, the precursor to a normal
recovery, will be slow to build.
The concerns relating to retail sales and
unemployment remain. More bad news will come.
But recent statistics have been mildly better
than expected. Inflation remains low, indeed
was negative for March, and companies are
cautiously rebuilding inventories after a
severe depletion late last year. Surveys of
purchasing managers and manufacturers have
improved. Recovery will be slow and painful,
but perhaps the worst is over and a return to
positive growth may occur by the third quarter
of 2009.
Credit and Bond Markets:
during the first quarter of 2009, interest
rates remained historically low with short
term rates as low as 40bp and 10-Year Treasury
notes, the rate from which mortgages and
corporate bonds price, trading firmly in the
2.5% to 3.0% range. The Fed signaled its
determination to keep rates low by announcing
a Treasury note purchase plan. This helped
market confidence in the short term, but is a
palliative only. For where interest rates are
headed, we must look at banks, new issuance
and inflation.
First, banks: no one knows
the level of bad loans but the International
Monetary Fund (IMF) recently updated its
forecast that the cumulative total could reach
$4.1 trillion, up from its estimate six months
ago of $1 trillion. While we await the stress
test results, there is little doubt that banks
are in awful shape. Why? One-off trading gains
and a re-write of the mark-to-market rules
flattered first quarter profits. The cost of
funding is close to zero so it is not
surprising that banks found a way to make
profits. One commentator likened it to
airlines making money if the cost of jet fuel
were free. It's not hard. Banks will depend
heavily on government-sponsored programs, and
this means, second, that
government borrowing and issuance will remain
high. In early May alone, we will see
refunding needs of over $300bn. For
perspective, global IPOs totaled less than
$1.9bn and Investment Grade bond issuances
have struggled to raise a net $36bn this year.
So crowding ensues. And, third,
if government debt creates artificial stimuli
and crowding, inflation cannot be far behind.
This may take a while to play out, for the
normal inflation indicators such as U.S.
Treasury's Inflation-Protected Securities
(TIPS), commodities and currencies are
unclear. But we remain vigilant.
Equities: the domestic
stock market fell in almost a straight line
from February to early March. But it quickly
rallied and we saw six weeks of improvement to
gain almost all of those losses back. The
market remains cautious, particularly toward
the financial sector, but has taken heart that
the worst for the global economy may be over.
Some of the indicators are:
- Volatility: the VIX index, also
known as the Street's fear gauge, trades
at one third of the level it approached in
October. This suggests investors are
taking on more risk and are more prepared
to ride out volatility.
- Fewer Sellers: hedge funds are no
longer the force they were. Most of their
forced selling was completed in the early
part of the year. Share buybacks, which
reached a cumulative total of $2.2
trillion or 20% of stock market
capitalization between 2002 and 2008, have
all but disappeared. This was always a
meager support to the market and their
absence creates a more solid foundation
for recovery.
- Earnings: for the S&P 500
companies for the first quarter, earnings
came in at 35% below the level of last
year's first quarter, their seventh
consecutive quarterly decline. But the
number of downgrades has improved and
share prices generally have fallen far
more than earnings. It seems as if the
market has priced in much bad news.
- Valuations: they are necessarily
predicated on past experience and can send
mixed signals. However, the positive yield
gap on equities compared to 10-Year
Treasuries and forward price earnings
ratios are in the high single digits. In
an environment of current low, real
interest rates, that suggests value.
In overseas markets, China looks promising.
It will likely be the only one of the world's
largest ten economies to show positive growth
in 2009. Most estimates are for 8% GDP growth.
China's fiscal expansion is targeted, domestic
and infrastructure- focused. Companies selling
into China are likely to see good years ahead.
Overall our investment strategy
concentrates on companies with strong balance
sheets, healthy dividend cover, visible order
books and earnings and strong management. It
is simple but not simplistic. We do not time.
Where we strive to succeed is through
long-term investing, knowing our companies and
examining and preparing for the downside risk.
We feel we can take heart from the current
signs.

|